Skip Navigation, Sitemap

Anglo Celt

Published: Wednesday, 14th April, 2010 5:00pm

Government must secure Quinn in Cavan

Comments (1) | Print | Email

The ongoing high drama surrounding Quinn Insurance has a perplexing affect on the nation as a whole and most particularly on the Quinn employees and the people of this area who have so much to lose if the wrong decisions are taken in terms of the future of the company.

Employees are rightly fearful for their jobs - they are hard workers, dedicated to what they do best as insurance underwriters and it seems as if their world has been turned upside in the last couple of weeks when the Financial Regulator secured the appointment of provisional administrators in a surprise High Court move.

There is intensive action at political and other levels to try and find a resolution but the decision of the High Court on Monday to adjourn the Financial Regulator's application seeking to confirm the appointment of the administrators means that the uncertainty continues.

It is difficult to comprehend that in a small State such as ours that there is such a divergence of thought between opinion makers in the capital and the plain people of Ireland. In the comments and analysis of the media intelligentsia the debate surrounding Quinn Insurance tends to be carried on in a financial abstract - that the socio-economic dynamic of the situation is brushed aside as if the difficulties of Quinn Insurance in terms of what it means to this area and to the employees is of secondary importance.

It is accepted that the rights of the policy holders are of particular regard but surely the future of over 3,000 jobs in this region and countless other downstream jobs carries its own weighty statement. The State is there to serve society and not the other way around. Perhaps in the euphoric land of the Celtic Tiger we accepted our view of the State as if it were a corporate entity - driven by the needs of the market. The collapse of that model should make us reflect on what is important. It is about families being able to have enough food on the table and being able to pay their way. The Quinn Group and Quinn Insurance have been providing that living for many, many people in Cavan and surrounding counties for decades now - surely this fact has societal implications that must be recognised by Government.

On Sunday the Minister for Agriculture and local TD, Brendan Smith, did forcefully emphasise the importance of Quinn Insurance and the Quinn Group to this region. However, there must be no equivocation about the necessity of protecting those jobs for this region - the entire Government must feel the same sense of urgency and concern as Brendan Smith. If those jobs are lost the pain and anguish caused will not be easily assuaged and its impact would most likely last for generations.

The people of this region, including our children and grandchildren would not thank those who let this happen. It is for that reason that a situation must be found that enables Quinn Insurance under the ownership of Sean Quinn to continue its insurance writing operation. Only under the Quinn management can the people of this area and the employees of the company rest easy that their future is secure.

Have your say. Post a comment on this article.

  • Frank Murphy


    Unregistered User
    Apr 15, 19:12
    Comment ID: 2944

    The country is broke and the "plain people of Ireland" have tough choices to make. I don't know what you mean by "opinion makers". If it is the elected parliament I agree that they are completely out of touch.

    The right course of action right now is not nearly as obvious are your commentary suggests. Even the Quinn Group did an about turn on its objection to the appointment of the administrator today. The country may end up spending money it doesn't have, which will affect future taxes and debt ratios. Do we want to risk escalating our financial woes, like (say) Greece or Iceland? With a higher tax burden, the country will be less competitive abroad and job creation and preservation becomes harder. Or the State may have to assume unreasonable risk and liabilities. Insurance is a really messy business when it goes bad.

    I feel very sorry for anybody whose job is at risk. Unemployment is a scourge. I hope jobs are saved because the government investment is justified given all the factors, rather than for politicial expediency. Many readers would find either reason acceptable in the short term, but may regret the outcome of more bailouts, when taxes are increased and public services cut yet again.



    It's a pity the Celt didn't point out that "the State is there to serve society" when fortunes were being made by wealthy individuals, and not now when people with very little are being asked to clean up the mess caused by the "irrational exuberance" of some very wealthy individuals.
    Report this comment

Post a comment

Registered users log in here

If you are registered with us, you can login here. If you are not registered, do so now.
Once logged in you wont have to complete word verification each time you post.

Prefer not to register?

Usernames must be 4 - 20 characters. Registration only takes a few minutes. Registered users can also take part in competitions and other features of the site.


Enter the text as shown.

 

I want to...

Vote

Anglo Celt Poll

Who should be the next Irish president?

This Poll is now closed.

Michael D Higgins (28.6%)

Gay Byrne (14.3%)

Gay Mitchell (20.4%)

Mary Davis (6.1%)

Brian Crowley (6.1%)

Other (24.5%)

News from around the Midlands