Prison or payback – the choice is yours
Woman warned in credit card fraud case
“PAY that money back — or go to prison for a very long time.”
That was the stark choice given by Judge Raymond Finnegan to a woman whose bank account was linked to a credit card fraud operation which had seen almost €48,000 taken from an unwitting third party.
Mozeedat Badru (23), with an address given at The Crescent, Millbourne, Ashbourne, Co Meath, had pleaded guilty at Monaghan District Court to three charges taken under the Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010 alleging that she had allowed sums totalling €10,580 be credited to her Permanent TSB account. The monies were transferred in two sums of €4,750 and one of €1,080 into her account at the bank’s branch at Killegland Street, Ashbourne, on February 20, 21 and 22, 2024.
Sergeant Lisa McEntee said the injured party in this case had received a telephone call from a person purporting to be from his bank, Permanent TSB. The victim had been exploited into providing codes relating to his debit card over the phone.
A number of fraudulent transactions followed, the sergeant said, through which the back account holder lost a total of €47,816. This money had been distributed to several other bank accounts, one of which was the PTSB account belonging to the accused.
Ms Badru had no previous convictions, Sgt McEntee said, and had stated that she made no personal financial gain from the scheme. But she was accepting that she was reckless, and had also insisted she was “pressurised” into becoming involved.
Defence barrister Joseph Smith was keen to emphasise to the court that his client had indeed been “manipulated” by another, trusted, wider family member.
He also contended that the gardaí would have found it difficult to bring a prosecution forward were not for Ms Badru’s cooperation, as it was she who had identified the primary perpetrator.
Judge Finnegan said he understood all that was being said, but that there was still “the burning question of €10,580”. That was the sum she would have to pay back, as she was a party to that amount of the money that was taken, “whether manipulated or not.”
Mr Smith reiterated his argument that the prosecution itself was accepting that his client made no personal financial gain. But Judge Finnegan countered that, if this were the case, she should go to the main person involved and get the money off them.
Pointing out that while Ms Badru’s partner was working, she herself was not, Mr Smith said he was seeking a long adjournment to allow her gather up the money. He didn’t want to mislead the court by giving the impression that compensation could be raised inside a short period.
Judge Finnegan, however, told the barrister his client already had almost three years in this regard, given that the incident occurred in February 2024.
The judge also remarked on how it baffled him that he had “never yet seen one of these money launderers who has benefited from allowing their account to be used”. He said his own attitude towards people like the defendant, who were “facilitating large criminal organisations”, was very well chronicled.
Judge Finnegan added that, while the court accepted that Ms Badru might have been manipulated, she had nevertheless allowed her account to be used and now had to “take ownership” of that fact.
Remanding her on continuing bail to January 25, 2027, he cautioned the defendant directly that she had to have full compensation in court on that date, whether she was a victim or not.
“And if you don’t you will go to prison for a very long period of time. The choice is yours,” Judge Finnegan warned her.
* This article was published with support from the Court Reporting Scheme