Old face stands between holders Scotstown and successive finals
By Colm Shalvey
A place in a second consecutive Ulster Club SFC Final is in Scotstown’s sights on Saturday evening in Enniskillen when they take on Donegal champions St. Eunan’s.
Kieran Donnelly has already made a winning return to Brewster Park to lead Eunan’s past Erne Gaels from his native Fermanagh, and he will now be bidding to get one over on the club where he won two Monaghan SFC titles as manager. Donnelly was in charge as Scotstown reached the 2018 Ulster decider, where they were pipped by Gaoth Dobhair after extra-time. Nine players who featured in that game at Healy Park remain involved for Scotstown, as does current selector Dónal Morgan. Extra-time has become a recurring theme for the Monaghan champions on the provincial scene, with their last three games in the competition going into am breise, most recently a dramatic one-point victory against Magherafelt.
David McCague will have been left with some injury concerns arising from that game; an intense encounter where they were uncharacteristically loose in possession, being turned over 25 times over the 80-plus minutes. Kieran Hughes was clearly hampered for much of the game and eventually had to go off, while Jack McCarron finished extra-time standing just on the pitch next to the tunnel after suffering an apparent ankle knock, with Scotstown having already used all of their available substitutions. They have enviable panel depth, as shown by Nicky Sherlock and Francis Maguire making a big impact after being drafted into the starting team last time out, but they will be keen to have everyone available as St. Eunan’s bid to atone for a series of narrow losses at this level.
The Letterkenny side are in their eighth tilt at Ulster since 2007, but they are still searching for a first final appearance. St. Eunan’s rode the crest of a wave this season, with their senior men and women and their hurlers all clinching county titles. Two of those wins arrived by the narrowest of margins, including the men’s win over Naomh Conaill, with a decisive late score from Ciarán Moore.
The younger of the two Conor O’Donnells has racked up 1-35 in the current campaign, with Eoin McGeehin, Shane O’Donnell, Moore, James Kelly and Eoin Dowling also reaching double figures. Niall O’Donnell has been travelling across the Atlantic to add to their attacking options, although he missed the Erne Gaels game due to work commitments. Ryan O’Toole and Damien McArdle will have key roles in attempting to deal with the likes of Conor O’Donnell Jnr. and McGeehin. At the back, Eunan’s have conceded just four goals in their eight championship matches to date. Caolán Ward and Conor O’Donnell Snr. anchor their defence, while they also have a top-class keeper in Shaun Patton, whose father, Peter, sadly passed away earlier this month.
Eunan’s will be hoping to learn some lessons from Magherafelt, who were able to lock down some of Scotstown’s key threats, limiting the holders to two two-pointers after they had raised 14 orange flags in their previous two games. McCague’s side have so many scoring threats, though, with Shane Carey and Tommy Mallen’s goals helping to guide them past the Derry champions. Max Maguire could return on Saturday to boost their firepower up front. Mícheál McCarville could be rejoined at midfield by Gavin McPhillips, who came off the bench in the last round, with the experience of the Hughes brothers and Rory Beggan also set to be vital for An Bhoth.
These games so often boil down to narrow margins and the ability of either keeper to pick out their team-mates’ runs could be central to the result. Beggan has been Scotstown’s trump card in several big games and while he was restricted to just one two-point free by Magherafelt, he still had a major influence on the result by making a couple of vital saves. The recent history of this competition tells us to expect nothing straightforward, but Scotstown’s greater experience should stand to them as they bid to qualify for their tenth final.