Vinny Corey was the latest manager to suffer defeat in the Ulster Club SFC. Photo: Adrian Donohoe

Dismal football year should prompt overdue debate

By Paul Fitzpatrick

With Lacken’s exit at the hands of impressive Tyrone champions Fintona, all three of Cavan’s senior, intermediate and junior champions have now bowed out of Ulster.

Contrary to common perception, which is clouded by the run of losses at senior club level, Cavan’s respective champions have been very competitive in the provincial championships in recent seasons. In the seven renewals of the Ulster club championships since 2018, there has been only one year – 2019 – in which none of the county’s representatives reached a provincial final. On that occasion, Killinkere came agonisingly close, losing after extra time to eventual champions Blackhill in the junior semi-final.

Mullahoran, Cuchulainns, Ballyhaise, Denn, Drumlane and Arva (twice) have all reached Ulster finals in that period, recording two wins and suffering three narrow defeats, two by a point and another in a penalty shoot-out.

This year, however, brought a decline in the county’s fortunes at club level and, unfortunately, it was very much in keeping with the wider picture. The sad reality, as we write in mid-November, is that 2026 was one of Cavan’s worst football years in living memory, across the board.

The senior inter-county team won just twice. The U20s exited the Ulster championship at the quarter-final stage, the minors in the semi-final, while our three adult club champions managed two provincial wins between them, both in the junior grade.

By any measure, that represents a poor return. And what makes it more concerning is the apparent lack of alarm – can you detect a sense of urgency, a demand for change, among the grassroots? The football people in the clubs seem weary and cynical, almost resigned to the situation.

It is obvious that things will not fix themselves. Assertive action is required and the forum in which that change must be driven is at county board level. Unfortunately, there appears to be an apathy among delegates which is deeply unhealthy. Impassioned debate is a thing of the past.

Compare and contrast with the ladies football board where there have been fractures, officers stepping down mid-tenure and various mini-controversies. Those conditions are far from ideal, of course, and we’re not suggesting that such turmoil is a positive but it demonstrates one thing – people really care about ladies football.

And, crucially, the ladies board has been producing winning teams, which is the acid test. Winning, as we know, justifies everything, more or less. Losing should bring it all into question.

This column is not just having a bash at the powers that be. While we have pointed out before that Cavan county board has an image problem, it’s also true to say that county boards are easy targets. They make fixtures, appoint managers, select referees and take all manner of decisions which inevitably leave somebody unhappy. And they do it with the best of intentions, mostly on a volunteer basis.

Sports administration has never been more demanding; there are layers of bureaucracy which simply did not exist in the past. The GAA occupies a unique position in Irish life and, as a result, tries – and is expected – to be all things to all men. To a large extent, it succeeds but it means that a huge amount is asked of volunteers at both club and county levels.

On his retirement in early 2023, former county secretary Liam McCabe recalled, in an interview on these pages, his first forays into administration as a 17-year-old secretary of Belturbet Rory O’Moores.

“There was no big deal about it at the time, that’s the way it was those times. There was nothing really with clubs back then only fixtures, that’s all you had to worry about really,” Liam recalled.

How things have changed. Club officers are now burdened with a multitude of additional responsibilities, as are those serving on the county board executive. In such circumstances, the actual performance of teams – once paramount– can easily slip down the list of priorities.

We’re all guilty of taking the path of least resistance, too. The reality is that it is easier to build a new stand, or whatever capital project you care to mention, than it is to build a winning team.

A stand requires finance and a degree of organisational planning. Constructing successful teams means examining culture, making difficult decisions, demanding accountability and risking offending people. That is an altogether different proposition.

Fresh thinking is needed, too. Cavan county board could do with an injection of new blood. The majority of the officers been involved in various committees for decades. They have given tremendous service but it’s past time that others got involved to lighten the load. Then again, as we have pointed out, who has the time or inclination for that any more?

Conversations

What is certain is that the current format is not conducive to the conversations that need to be had. Anyone who attends county board meetings will know that impassioned debate is a rarity. Perhaps it takes place behind closed doors at executive meetings – they can get a bit more feisty - but there is precious little evidence of it in the public forum.

McCabe identified this problem three years ago when he called for a “shake-up” in how county board meetings were conducted.

“There’s not enough interactions between clubs and county board at those meetings. I think we should have a look at it, maybe have a subject tonight and discuss that as a topic rather than just going in and reading reports, reports, reports.

“We were dealing with over 2 million euros this year and not one person asked a question. Nobody said well done or what are you doing? And at times, yeah, it is frustrating that people won’t ask questions because that’s what we’re there for – we’re there to answer questions. Nobody should be afraid to ask a question.”

He recalled a particularly tame convention, after which one delegate became animated in the bar.

“I remember one night in Virginia there was a convention, very, very quiet. We came down and a certain gentleman in the bar started talking about, ‘oh, this should be done…’. I said, ‘Hold on a minute, we’re after being two hours up there, that’s the place where that should be raised, not down here’.”

Roots

The historical context is important. Reading Frank Shovlin’s new biography of John McGahern recently brought home just how deep the roots of Gaelic football run here. McGahern and his father attended the 1948 All-Ireland senior football final, watching Cavan defeat Mayo by a point. That was almost 80 years ago.

The father, Frank, came from Corratober in Gowna and, Shovlin relates, was a useful footballer himself, lining out at left full-back on the Gowna team in 1918, according to team lists published in this newspaper. That was almost 110 years ago and the GAA was already more than three decades old in Co Cavan at that stage. The games, then, have persisted through a lot; Cavan have been at low ebbs before and bounced back.

Looking at the flagship team, the senior county panel was gutted last year and, given the spate of withdrawals this winter, will be almost unrecognisable in 2027. If we’re being optimistic, maybe that will prove a blessing in disguise. Who knows? For all the gloom, we must still keep the faith.

The last word goes to McGahern’s contemporary, and a man of whom it is said he wasn’t overly fond, Seamus Heaney.

“That passed over,” wrote the Derryman, “this can too.”