Calls for major overhaul of Residential Tenancies Board
The Residential Tenancies Board (RTB) came under fire from Cavan councillors at their November monthly meeting, with demands for a major overhaul of the organisation.
Fianna Fáil councillor John Paul Feeley delivered a particularly sharp criticism of the board, calling for it to be reconstituted to ensure it better represents tenants while also recognising the needs and concerns of landlords.
Cllr Feeley said his latest frustration arose after contacting the RTB on behalf of a constituent. During the telephone conversation, he said, the person dealing with his query would only provide their first name, citing organisational “policy”.He described the experience as the latest in a long list of grievances with an organisation he finds increasingly difficult to engage with.
Acknowledging that there are good and bad landlords, just as there are good and bad tenants, he said the problem lay in the extraordinary difficulties people face when attempting to get a response or have complaints addressed.
“It is the most unresponsive organisation,” he fumed.
He also questioned the effectiveness of the RTB's decisions, pointing out that even when individuals secure an order through the board, they may still have to go before a local judge to have it enforced.
“No wonder many landlords are leaving the system,” he said, arguing that the RTB had played a “role” in driving people away from the rental sector.Branding the situation a “disgrace”, Cllr Feeley contrasted the experience of dealing with the board with that of engaging with the local authority.
When people have a complaint about the council, he said, they at least have somewhere to direct their concerns, with elected representatives and council staff available to assist.
He suggested that the RTB operates on an entirely different level, leaving people struggling to get answers and meaningful assistance.
The criticism comes against the backdrop of significant changes to rental legislation in 2026, with new tenant protections, revised rent-control arrangements and changes to the circumstances in which tenancies can be terminated taking effect from March 1. Further reforms in September were also outlined as strengthening the board's enforcement powers and introducing additional transparency measures.
Independent Ireland councillor Shane P. O'Reilly also supported calls for change, suggesting that data protection regulation is frequently used by State organisations as a shield when “afraid” to deal with difficult questions.
He expressed particular sympathy for so-called “accidental landlords” - people who inherit a property and suddenly find themselves responsible for meeting the obligations and expectations of the rental market. Cllr O'Reilly said there is a need for an organisation capable of advocating on behalf of tenants, while questioning the value being delivered by the RTB at what he described as “enormous expense”.
He went further, declaring that the organisation was “not fit for use” in its current form.
“I don't want to see another quango set up, another drain on resources and no change,” he warned, making clear that any reform should deliver meaningful improvements rather than simply create another layer of bureaucracy.
Fianna Fáil councillor Clifford Kelly backed the motion too, as did Independent councillor Brendan Fay, who spoke of his own deeply frustrating experiences attempting to deal with the RTB.
Fianna Fáil's Patricia Walsh said it appeared that everyone attempting to engage with the organisation was being given the “runaround”.
Fine Gael councillors Niamh Brady, TP O'Reilly and Trevor Smith also supported the call for reform.
Cathaoirleach Carmel Brady added her own criticism, recalling her experience working in a solicitor's office in a previous role, when she said the RTB was the “absolute bane” of their working day.