"Regarding things being thrown into hedgerows, it is a person's own responsibility not to throw things out of cars," said Cllr. Sean McKiernan.

Recycling centre only recoups one fifth of cost

Published: Fri 9 Jul 2010, 10:00 AM

Bailieborough Recycling Centre brought in €40,000 in revenue to Cavan County Council in 2009 - but the gross cost of running the centre was €190,000, it was revealed at the June meeting of Cavan County Council. "We are recovering 21% of the cost of operating the facility," director of service, Joe McLoughlin told members of Cavan County Council in the context of a discussion about the €3 charge that was introduced for use of the centre. Councillor Fergal Curtin raised a discussion about the charge and opening hours. "I'm wondering if there is any link between the €3 charge and illegal dumping," he said, complimenting staff on how well run the centre is. He also called for later opening hours one or two evenings a week, commenting that "easier use and access may encourage people to avail of the service". Cllr. Paddy McDonald agreed that "the charge is discouraging people", but other members were strong in their disagreement. "I can fill a Caddy van and empty it for €3?" exclaimed Cllr. Maura Maguire Lynch. "You wouldn't even give that to a child to go to the shops!" Cllr. Charlie Boylan agreed: "The charge of €3 might seem excessive to some people, but I think it's very good value. It's not even the price of a pint, nor half the price of a packet of cigarettes," said Cllr. Boylan. "There is a perception that the local authority makes money from recycling... This is not the case," said Cllr. Sean McKiernan, asking the executive to highlight the costs involved. He commented that much illegal dumping consists of items that can't be recycled at the centre, for example, tyres. "I am not sure if there is a link. Regarding things being thrown into hedgerows, it is a person's own responsibility not to throw things out of cars," said Cllr. McKiernan. "I believe 90% of people acknowledge that Bailieborough Recycling Centre is a great resource." Revealing the figures for the centre, Mr. McLoughlin also informed members that there had been no drop in the number of tonnes of waste collected, which suggests that the charge is not a deterrent, he said.