Director of Schools, Paddy Flood.

Lack of sub teachers and space a ‘nightmare’

The word “nightmare” was used more than once by different speakers to describe problems around a lack of accommodation and substitute teachers at second level schools in the region.

The Director of Schools for the Cavan Monaghan Education and Training Board (CMETB), Paddy Flood, told the November Board meeting that schools have been struggling to find supply teachers this year.

He is putting the lack of school accommodation - classrooms, labs, teaching rooms and halls – down to an increase in student numbers.

“A few years ago, we used to have less than 4,000 students and now we have over 6,000,” he said. “We are working hard at staffing and admissions, but we don’t have the accommodation,” the director pointed out.

The Director of Schools also raised the lack of substitute teachers this year saying the theme of the issue is “treading water”.

“Principals really are very busy at the moment trying to cover classes and the curriculum because there are less available sub teachers.

“Treading water is the theme here,” said Paddy Flood.

He said despite a common perception that Ireland has lost many teachers to Australia, New Zealand and the Middle East, “there are more teachers returning than leaving”.

The director pointed to how four years ago, there was a lack of Home Economics teachers in the CMETB region, last year it was English teachers and this year, schools need more Maths and Science teachers.

Mr Flood said the growth in special education played some part in these deficiencies because teachers are coming out of the roles for which they are specifically qualified to teach in the special needs sector.

Another contributing factor is leaves of absence.

“We have grown the number of teachers in recent years,” Mr Flood said. “But teachers can take a career break of up to five years and the number of leaves we can take as teachers has increased.”

Monaghan County Councillor and former principal of St Louis Convent School in Monaghan Town up until last year, Margaret Conlon, described the substitute situation as a “nightmare”.

“It’s a nightmare for principals,” she said. “When it comes to minority subjects like Physics, for example, graduates see better opportunities and progression in the private sector and industry.”

The Fianna Fáil councillor said many qualified teachers are not interested in substitute work because “you’re often not guaranteed more than a week”.

Substitute teachers are more likely to wait for an opening to cover someone’s maternity leave instead, she asserted.

The recently retired principal also lamented: “There is no understanding or acceptance by students and parents that there is no bank of substitute teachers for you to use, either.”

Mr Flood returned to the issue of teachers’ leave when he said: “There are 33 different leaves that teachers can avail of. It’s a nightmare but you have to grant most of it because it’s statutory leave.

“We as an employer, what we’ve done in the past,” he continued, “is we tend to be generous with leave because our teacehers are our greatest asset, but the cumulative effect of this is quite disabling.”

Weighing in on the discussion, Joe McGrath, who serves on the board as a nominated member representing the National Association of Principals & Deputy Principals (NAPD) said the “shortage of teachers has been going on for a number of years”.

“Teaching is not an easy job; not everyone can do it,” he said. “Some people get the qualifications but then can’t do the job.”

The former principal suggested that ETBs like the one in Cavan and Monaghan “focus on our own people”.

“When you see a student with the skills for teaching and, in say, subjects like Home Economics, that we focus on that and on our people. Give students encouragement to consider teaching as a job, give them work experience,” Mr McGrath said.