Cllr Noel Connell (SF).

War of words over neutrality motion

A motion calling for a referendum on Irish neutrality passed at the November meeting of Cavan County Council following a lively debate in which elected members expressed sharply differing views on the Government’s proposals to change rules governing overseas deployments of defence personnel.

Proposed by Sinn Féin councillor Noel Connell, the motion called on both the Taoiseach and Minister for Defence, Helen McEntee, to put the proposed dismantling of the Triple Lock to a referendum and allow the Irish people decide the future direction of the country’s neutrality.

Cllr Connell warned that removing the mechanism would represent a serious breach of assurances previously given to the electorate during past European treaty referendums.

“Irish neutrality belongs to the Irish people. It is not the property of any Taoiseach, minister or any government to bargain away,” he declared.

Cllr Connell also reminded that the Triple Lock requires three separate approvals before more than 12 Irish Defence Forces personnel can participate in overseas missions: by Cabinet, Dáil Éireann and a United Nations mandate, either from the Security Council or General Assembly.

Cllr Connell pointed to the 2001 Nice Treaty Referendum, when Irish voters initially rejected the treaty amid concerns about Ireland being drawn into European military structures.

He argued that assurances on neutrality, including the introduction of the Triple Lock through a solemn declaration, were instrumental in securing public support for it and subsequent treaties.

“When the Government wanted support for the Nice and Lisbon treaties, it gave assurances on neutrality. Now it wants to tear those assurances up, and that is a very serious breach of trust,” Cllr Connell said at the meeting, maintaining that Ireland’s proud peacekeeping tradition should be protected and the Government should be investing in Defence Forces personnel rather than dismantling safeguards around overseas deployment.

“Sinn Féin’s position is clear. Retain the Triple Lock, defend Irish neutrality and honour the promises made to the Irish people,” he said.

‘No place in foreign wars’

Seconding the motion, Sinn Féin councillor Stiofán Conaty warned the proposed changes caused considerable concern among people fearing Ireland could become increasingly entangled in international military alliances.

“People are very concerned about security,” he said, but added that there was also widespread unease about Ireland being “asked to jump into bed” with military alliances.

“We have no place as combatants in foreign wars,” he stated.

Cllr Conaty highlighted how its often “working-class people” who ultimately bear the consequences of military conflicts, describing the danger of ordinary soldiers being sent abroad as “cannon fodder”.

He argued that removing the Triple Lock represented the “latest step” in what he viewed as an erosion of Irish neutrality.

Challenge

Fine Gael’s Trevor Smith was the first councillor to speak in opposition to the motion’s underlying argument, arguing that Irish neutrality and the Triple Lock are “two separate issues”.

He questioned whether it was appropriate for countries such as China or Russia to effectively have a “veto” over when and where Irish troops could be deployed.

That argument was echoed by Fianna Fáil councillor Clifford Kelly, who said he saw “no danger” in abolishing the Triple Lock in terms of the risk of undermining Ireland’s neutrality.

Cllr Patricia Walsh (Fianna Fáil), whose husband and two sons have served with the Defence Forces, including multiple overseas tours in Chad, Lebanon and the Golan Heights, spoke passionately about the contribution made by Irish military personnel.

She said service men and women had consistently done the country “proud” and highlighted the pride felt by families as Defence Forces personnel prepared for another deployment to Lebanon.

“We’re all so proud,” she said.

“I don’t think our neutrality is under threat,” she added, pointing out that Irish Defence Forces personnel are “highly trained to do their job”.

Serving soldier’s message

Independent Ireland councillor Shane P. O’Reilly read a text message, which he said he had received from a serving member of the Defence Forces.

The message questioned why the very people who would ultimately be deployed overseas had not been given a direct voice in the debate about removing the Triple Lock.

“As serving members in the Irish Defence Forces, who live this life every day and have served overseas for our country and don the tricolour every day with pride.

“Why are we not being asked to vote on the removal of the Triple Lock?” the message asked.

It continued with a warning about the potential consequences for serving personnel. “We will be used as pawns to reinforce the Government’s political ideology and personal agendas, with little to no protection.”

The serving member argued that politicians making decisions about overseas deployments would not be the ones boarding aircraft or travelling in armoured vehicles into dangerous situations and terrains.

“The men and women making the decision to remove the Triple Lock are not the men and women, fathers and mothers, sons and daughters, brothers and sisters who will be on the plane or in the back of the armoured vehicles in God knows where, facing God knows what,” read Cllr O’Reilly.

The message also questioned how Ireland’s peacekeeping role might evolve if the Government was given greater freedom to participate in overseas military missions.

“While we may brand the term peacekeepers for now, how long will that stand when we are forced to aid one side of whatever war or mission the Government sees fit at the time?” asked the soldier.

“I am not saying we don’t want this. I am not saying we do want this. I am saying OUR opinions should be heard more than anyone’s.”

Speaking freely, Cllr O’Reilly said Patricia Walsh had “sacrificed more than most” in the council chamber, given the personal and family connections she had to the Defence Forces.

He also revealed that, as a former Fianna Fáil member, he had campaigned for the Nice Treaty and remembered the assurances given by the Government regarding the Triple Lock.

“That’s now being reneged upon, and we have to ask why?” asked Cllr O’Reilly, who further questioned why the Irish electorate would not be given an opportunity to vote on such a significant change.

“Let the Irish people have their say. What are they afraid of? Let it be put to the people.”

‘Neutrality is cherished’

Fianna Fáil councillor John Paul Feeley said Irish people are proud of the country’s tradition of neutrality, which stretches back to the Second World War.

He described neutrality as something “cherished very dearly” and noted that debates about its future had accompanied successive European treaty referendums since Ireland joined the EU.

“No matter how well we arm ourselves, we are not going to be a great military nation,” he told his fellow elected members.

However, he questioned whether the existing Triple Lock arrangements remained appropriate in the current international environment, pointing out that the UN is “not functioning” as it should.

Cllr Feeley said the international circumstances that existed following the break-up of the Soviet Union had since changed considerably, particularly with the emergence of modern threats such as cyberterrorism and cyberattacks.

While agreeing that no individual country within the UN should have a veto over another nation’s military participation, he made it clear he was opposed to Ireland joining alliances such as NATO.

He also stressed that changing the Triple Lock did not necessarily mean Ireland was surrendering its “sovereignty”.

“I don’t think we should be afraid to make up our own minds,” he said.

Cllr Feeley added that, if the referendum proposal was specifically about Ireland’s neutrality, he would support that. However, he believed the operation of the Triple Lock was ultimately a matter of “national policy”.

Misinformation

Fine Gael’s Winston Bennett said he would be “totally against” holding a referendum on the Triple Lock.

Fianna Fáil councillor Áine Smith also read from a message she said she had received from a serving member of the Defence Forces.

She warned that public discussion of the Triple Lock and neutrality was becoming confused by misinformation and misleading commentary, especially circulating on social media.

She said the motivations of those spreading such material needed to be scrutinised.

“It’s something people have to wise up to,” she remarked, hinting at potential undue influence from foreign actors looking to disrupt normal discourse around the issue.

The message she read reflected the position that Ireland should not surrender control over military deployment decisions to foreign powers, and that decisions concerning the deployment of Irish troops should “remain within” Dáil Éireann.

Responding to the various contributions, Cllr Noel Connell clarified that his proposal was ultimately calling for a referendum on Ireland’s position on “neutrality” into the future.

He reiterated that the Triple Lock remained a “very important” part of this, but stated that Irish people should have an opportunity to decide the country’s position rather than having such a significant issue determined solely by the Government.

Cllr Conaty, who supported that position, pointed to the “wording” of the motion, before arguing again that the proposed removal of the Triple Lock appeared to be the latest step towards undermining neutrality.

The motion was supported by Independent Ireland’s Shane P. O’Reilly, and with no counter-proposal brought forward, the motion was passed without challenge.

* This article was published with support from the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme