Around the Houses...

Reform of outdated ‘in camera’ rule discussed

A Dáil debate on reforming Ireland’s family law system has highlighted growing pressure to replace the long-standing “in camera” rule, with calls for greater transparency balanced against child protection.

Independent Deputy Paul Nicholas Gogarty’s motion argued that the rule, which keeps family law proceedings private, has “left children exposed to emotional harm, re-traumatisation, and unsafe contact,” and contributed to distress, depression and even suicidal thoughts. It also warned that secrecy can fuel conflict and poor decision-making, hindering children’s development.

Supporting the motion, Sinn Féin’s Matt Carthy said the issue arises “weekly, if not more regularly,” in his role as justice committee chair. He cited evidence from victims of domestic violence who felt “silenced by the rule,” arguing it “severely limited accountability” and allowed harmful behaviour to go “unchallenged behind closed doors.” He also criticised delays in broader family court reform, saying progress has been “far too slow.”

In response, Minister of State Michael Moynihan said the Government is committed to improving transparency while protecting privacy. He pointed to ongoing reviews of the rule and international models, including reforms in England and Wales allowing media attendance with strict anonymity safeguards.

“The Minister… is committed to the ongoing reform of the family justice system to improve the rights and protections of children and families,” he said. The Minister added that new initiatives, such as a family law reporting project and pilot programmes to amplify the “voice of the child,” aim to build trust and inform future legislation.

While no immediate legislative overhaul was confirmed, the Government signalled that reforms are under active consideration.

AI geared towards SME productivity

The Government has said it is intensifying efforts to help small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) translate growing awareness of artificial intelligence (AI) into real productivity gains, amid concerns about uneven adoption.

Responding to concerns raised by Deputy Aindrias Moynihan about a potential “two-speed economy,” Minister of State for Trade, Artificial Intelligence and Digital Transformation Niamh Smyth emphasised that many SMEs are still at an early stage and need practical support to move beyond initial use cases.

“The Government is committed to ensuring Irish businesses can adopt and benefit from AI,” she said, adding that many firms are seeking “practical guidance on applying AI across core business functions.” The Minister pointed to increased support through enterprise agencies, including case studies, sector-specific examples and hands-on guidance to demonstrate tangible business benefits.

Recent data highlights growing uptake, with over 20% of Irish enterprises using AI in 2025, up from 15% in 2024. SME adoption has also risen to 13.8%, now above the EU average.

The Government’s Digital Ireland strategy aims to accelerate this progress, particularly among SMEs. Initiatives include a national AI awareness roadshow delivered through Local Enterprise Offices, showcasing real-world success stories and available supports. Additional measures include the appointment of AI sector champions and the creation of OBAIR, a new Observatory for Business AI Readiness, designed to track adoption and identify barriers.

Minister Smyth said these measures are focused on ensuring SMEs can “understand the practical benefits of AI and digital tools” and apply them effectively across their operations.

ASKED AND ANSWERED: Increased costs for Council’s road repairs since oil price soar

Senator Robbie Gallagher asked in light of the increasingly critical condition of regional and local roads in counties like Cavan and Monaghan, how does the Government intend to address the growing gap between available funding and actual maintenance needs, particularly given rising costs linked to global oil prices? Monaghan County Council reported cost increases of around 25% for road materials such as bitumen and tar. 400 km of its roads are now classified as being in “very poor” condition - almost double the national average.

The estimated cost of addressing part of this backlog has risen sharply from €33 million in 2024 to €46 million. “More than a quarter of it’s annual budget is dedicated to road maintenance.”

Similarly, County Cavan faces an estimated €234 million bill to repair over 1,100 km of deteriorated roads, yet only about €55 million has been allocated for priority works. “A drop in the ocean,” said the Senator. These shortfalls are already impacting daily life, with disruptions to school transport and difficulties for essential services such as home care providers accessing rural areas.

Given the reliance on road transport in rural Ireland and the additional financial pressures caused by global events, will the Government provide additional, targeted funding to counties like Cavan and Monaghan to prevent further deterioration and ensure safe, functional road networks?

Minister Michael Moynihan responded that the Government recognises the pressures on road maintenance arising from weather damage and rising material costs. It has allocated €718 million this year for regional and local roads, representing a continued increase in Exchequer funding. This funding supports key programmes focused on road protection, restoration, and maintenance, with local authorities responsible for prioritising works and supplementing funding from their own resources.

The Minister of State acknowledged that rising oil prices - linked to the ongoing conflict in the Middle East - are increasing costs and may impact the delivery of planned works. “We have put in place over €750 million of funding to help people who are severely affected by oil prices, but the Senator’s point about additional funding is one I will take back to the Department of Transport.”

He emphasised the Government’s commitment to maintaining the road network, particularly in rural areas where connectivity is vital, and has pledged to continue monitoring the situation.